Deep Work vs. Multitasking: Which is Better for Productivity?

You’ve got a long to-do list, and the clock is ticking. So, what’s your strategy? Do you open ten tabs, answer emails while listening to a podcast, and jump between tasks like a productivity jumprope? Or do you block out time, silence notifications, and focus on one deep, uninterrupted task?

For years, multitasking has been celebrated as a superpower—a skill that lets us juggle multiple responsibilities at once. We see it as a way to get more done in less time, responding to Slack messages while drafting a report, checking emails between meetings, and brainstorming ideas while scrolling social media.

But what if that approach is actually slowing us down?

Deep work, a state of undistracted concentration, is often overlooked in favor of the hustle-and-grind culture. Yet, research suggests that it might be the key to doing better work in less time—without feeling mentally drained by the end of the day.

So, which is better for productivity? Multitasking or deep work? Let’s break it down.

The modern workplace often glorifies multitasking—we’re told to juggle Slack messages, emails, and deadlines like it’s an Olympic sport. But research suggests that deep work, a state of undistracted concentration, might be the real key to getting meaningful work done.

So, which is better for productivity? Let’s break it down.

What is Multitasking?

Multitasking is the art of doing multiple things at once—or at least, that’s what we like to think. In reality, most of what we call “multitasking” is actually rapid task-switching, where our brain jumps from one activity to another rather than truly handling multiple things at once.

For example, if you’re replying to emails while watching a webinar, your brain isn’t absorbing both equally. Instead, it’s constantly switching focus, leading to shallow work rather than deep engagement.

🔹 The Myth of Multitasking: Research shows that only about 2.5% of people can truly multitask efficiently. The rest of us experience “task-switching costs”—the cognitive energy lost when switching between different activities.

🔹 Why It Feels Productive: Multitasking can create an illusion of efficiency because we’re always busy. However, studies from Stanford University suggest that heavy multitaskers are actually less productive and more prone to distractions than those who focus on one task at a time.

What is Deep Work?

Deep Work, a term popularized by author Cal Newport, refers to a state of undistracted, high-focus work. It’s when you enter “flow,” where creativity and efficiency skyrocket because your brain isn’t constantly shifting gears. This is the opposite of multitasking. Instead of bouncing between different tasks, you’re dedicating your full attention to one meaningful activity.

🔹 The Benefits of Deep Work: When you eliminate distractions and focus on a single task, you engage in cognitive depth—allowing you to produce higher-quality work in less time.

🔹 How It Works: Deep work typically involves:

• Blocking distractions (no social media, notifications, or emails).
• Focusing on one task for extended periods (30-90 minutes).
• Using structured breaks to maintain mental energy.

Why Deep Work Outperforms Multitasking

Multitasking may seem efficient, but it lowers cognitive performance and reduces retention of information. Let’s compare the two approaches:

• Cognitive Load: Deep work requires less mental strain because your brain isn’t constantly shifting focus. Multitasking, however, creates mental fatigue due to continuous switching.
• Speed & Accuracy: A University of London study found that multitaskers experience IQ drops similar to those who pulled an all-nighter. Deep work improves accuracy and speed since your mind is fully engaged.
• Creativity & Problem-Solving: Deep work enables deeper connections and insights. Multitasking disrupts thought patterns, making it harder to generate new ideas.

How to Shift from Multitasking to Deep Work

If you’re used to bouncing between tasks, transitioning to deep work takes practice and intentionality. Here’s how to start:

✅ Use the Pomodoro Timer Method – Work for 25-45 minutes, then take a 5-minute break. Repeat this cycle to stay productive without burnout.

✅ Enable Focus Mode on iPhone – Silence distractions by setting up Work Focus Mode to block notifications from non-essential apps.

✅ Time Block Your Day – Dedicate specific hours for deep work and batch similar tasks together (e.g., answering emails in one time slot instead of throughout the day).

✅ Create a Distraction-Free Workspace – Whether you’re working from home or a coworking space, set up a clutter-free, aesthetically pleasing environment that encourages focus.

✅ Limit Open Tabs – Research from Princeton University shows that cluttered screens contribute to cognitive overload. Try using a single-screen workspace to improve focus.

Final Thoughts: The Verdict? Deep Work Wins

While multitasking can be useful for small, low-effort tasks, it’s not an effective way to tackle meaningful projects. Deep work, on the other hand, allows you to work smarter, not harder, producing higher-quality results with less stress.

If you feel like your productivity is scattered, challenge yourself to try deep work for a week. Turn on Focus Mode, use a Pomodoro timer, and give your brain the space it needs to enter a state of flow. You might just be surprised at how much more you can accomplish.

‍