Have you ever had one of those days where you try to juggle too many things at once, only to end up feeling scattered and unproductive? You’re not alone. Multitasking has been glamorized as the ultimate productivity hack, but research tells a different story. Enter batching, a strategy rooted in focused effort that might just be the antidote to our multitasking overload.

So, how do these two styles stack up? Let’s dive into the science and see which approach works best for you.

What Is Batching?

Batching is the practice of grouping similar tasks together and completing them in dedicated blocks of time. Instead of jumping between emails, brainstorming, and meetings, you focus solely on one category of tasks before moving to the next.

Think:

  • Writing all your emails for the day in one sitting.
  • Editing a week’s worth of social media content in one session.
  • Planning your meals for the week in one go.

The goal is to reduce context switching—the mental cost of constantly shifting gears between unrelated tasks.

The Problem with Multitasking

Multitasking might seem like a superpower, but studies reveal it’s more of a kryptonite. Here’s why:

  1. Reduced Cognitive Efficiency: The human brain isn’t wired to focus on multiple tasks simultaneously. Instead, it toggles between tasks, which slows down processing speed.
  2. Increased Errors: Research from the American Psychological Association shows that multitasking can lead to mistakes, especially with complex or detail-oriented work.
  3. Mental Fatigue: Constantly switching tasks depletes your mental energy faster, leaving you feeling drained and less productive.
  4. Lower Quality Work: Divided attention often results in shallow work, where tasks are completed but lack depth or creativity.

The Science of Batching

Unlike multitasking, batching leverages the brain’s natural preference for sustained focus. Studies on cognitive flow—the state where you’re fully immersed in a task—show that uninterrupted time blocks allow for deeper work and better results.

Batching also:

  • Reduces Decision Fatigue: Fewer transitions between tasks mean fewer decisions about what to focus on next.
  • Boosts Creativity: Staying in one type of work (e.g., writing) helps ideas flow without interruption.
  • Increases Efficiency: Repeatedly performing similar actions creates momentum, saving time and mental energy.

Which Style Is Right for You?

While batching and multitasking represent two ends of the productivity spectrum, your ideal style depends on your work habits and the nature of your tasks. Here’s how to figure out what works best for you:

1. Understand Your Tasks

Multitasking works better for simple, repetitive tasks (e.g., folding laundry while listening to a podcast). Batching is ideal for creative or high-focus tasks that require deep concentration.

2. Track Your Energy Levels

If you find that multitasking leaves you frazzled, try batching during your most focused hours. Save lighter multitasking tasks for when your energy naturally dips.

3. Experiment and Reflect

Spend one week batching your work and another embracing multitasking. Notice how you feel at the end of each day. Which style leaves you more energized and accomplished?

How to Start Batching

If you’re curious to try batching, here’s how to make it work:

1. Group Similar Tasks Together

List out your daily tasks and categorize them. For example:

  • Emails and admin work
  • Creative tasks (writing, brainstorming, designing)
  • Meetings and calls

2. Schedule Dedicated Time Blocks

Assign specific times for each task group. For example, tackle all your emails between 10:00 and 11:00 a.m.

3. Eliminate Distractions

Use tools like “Do Not Disturb” on your phone or apps like Forest to keep your focus intact during batching sessions.

4. Take Breaks

Batching can be intense. Schedule short breaks between sessions to recharge and prevent burnout.

5. Evaluate and Adjust

Review your progress after a week. Are you completing more? Do you feel less stressed? Use this feedback to refine your approach.

Key Takeaways

  • Batching and multitasking are distinct productivity styles: batching involves focused, grouped work, while multitasking splits attention between tasks.
  • Multitasking hinders productivity, increasing errors and mental fatigue, while batching leverages the brain’s natural focus capabilities.
  • To find your ideal approach, assess your tasks and experiment with both styles.

‍